How to Take a Break from an Argument Without Making It Worse

Does taking a break during fights feel like abandonment or the silent treatment? Learn how to pause heated arguments productively, cool down without disconnecting, and return to resolve the issue without making things worse.

⚠️ Important Relationship Advice Disclaimer: This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered professional relationship counseling, therapy, or mental health advice. Relationship dynamics are highly individual and complex, involving unique personal histories, attachment patterns, mental health considerations, and interpersonal dynamics that require personalized professional guidance. The information provided here does not constitute professional counseling or therapy and should not be relied upon as a substitute for qualified mental health care. If you are experiencing relationship distress, mental health challenges, patterns of unhealthy relationships, or emotional difficulties, please consult with a licensed therapist, relationship counselor, or mental health professional who can provide personalized support tailored to your specific situation. Every relationship situation is unique and may require specialized professional intervention. The strategies discussed here are general in nature and may not be appropriate for all situations, particularly those involving abuse, manipulation, or mental health crises.

💡 Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the blog and allows me to continue providing free relationship advice and resources. I only recommend products, services, and resources that I believe genuinely help you build healthier relationships and improve your romantic life. Thank you for your support!

Quick Answer:

Taking a break during an argument is healthy and necessary when emotions are too high for productive conversation—but HOW you take the break determines whether it helps or hurts. A good break includes: announcing you need a break ("I'm getting too upset to continue productively. I need 20 minutes to calm down"), setting a specific return time ("Let's come back to this in 20 minutes"), actually calming down during the break (not rehearsing arguments), and returning at the agreed time to continue the conversation. A bad break looks like: storming off without explanation, refusing to set a return time, using the break to avoid the issue entirely, or never coming back to resolve it. The difference between a healthy break and stonewalling/abandonment: healthy breaks are temporary pauses with intention to return; stonewalling is punishment through withdrawal with no plan to resolve. Take breaks when you're emotionally flooded (heart racing, can't think clearly, want to say something you'll regret), but don't use breaks to avoid difficult conversations or punish your partner. If one partner needs breaks and the other fears abandonment, both need to compromise: the break-taker commits to returning, the break-resister respects the need for space.

The Problem with How Most People Take Breaks

You're in the middle of a heated argument.

Things are escalating.

Voices are raised. Emotions are high. Someone's about to say something they'll regret.

One of you says:

"I need a break."

Or worse—just walks away without saying anything.

Now what happens depends on which person you are:

If YOU'RE the one who needs the break:

You leave to calm down.

But your partner experiences it as:

Abandonment
Rejection
Punishment
Being shut out
The silent treatment

They follow you, demanding:

"We need to finish this!"
"You're running away!"
"You always do this!"

Now you're more flooded because they won't let you have space.

If YOUR PARTNER takes the break:

They walk away mid-argument.

You experience it as:

Abandonment
Avoidance
Not caring enough to resolve it
Being left in emotional turmoil

You follow them, pleading:

"We need to talk about this!"
"Don't just walk away!"
"When are we going to resolve this?!"

Now they're more flooded because you're pursuing them.

Neither of you feels better.

The original issue doesn't get resolved.

Now you have TWO problems:

The original conflict
The fight about taking a break

Here's what you need to understand:

Taking breaks during arguments is HEALTHY and NECESSARY.

But how you take them determines everything.

Done right: Breaks allow you both to calm down and return to productive conversation.

Done wrong: Breaks feel like abandonment and make everything worse.

Let's learn to do it right.

Healthy Break vs. Stonewalling/Abandonment

There's a crucial difference you need to understand.

✅ HEALTHY BREAK:

What it is:
A temporary pause to calm down with clear intention and timeline to return and resolve the issue.

What it looks like:

"I'm getting too emotional to have a productive conversation right now. I need 20 minutes to calm down. Let's come back to this at [specific time]."

Then:

Actually returning at that time
Being willing to continue the conversation
Having calmed down during the break

Characteristics:

Communicated clearly
Specific timeframe
Intention to return
Actually returns
Issue gets addressed

❌ STONEWALLING/ABANDONMENT:

What it is:
Withdrawing to punish or avoid, with no intention to return to the conversation.

What it looks like:

[Storms off without saying anything]

Or: "I can't deal with this right now." [Leaves indefinitely]

Or: "I need space." [Refuses to say when they'll be available]

Then:

Not returning
Refusing to discuss it later
Acting like nothing happened
Giving the silent treatment for hours/days

Characteristics:

No communication
No timeframe
No intention to resolve
Punishment through withdrawal
Issue never addressed

THE KEY DIFFERENCES:

Healthy break:

"I'll be back in 20 minutes"
Specific timeline
Intention to resolve
Actually returns

Stonewalling:

No timeframe or indefinite
No intention to return
Avoiding/punishing
Never resolves

One is self-care and emotional regulation.

The other is avoidance and emotional abuse.

When You SHOULD Take a Break

Not every argument needs a break. Here's when you do.

SIGN #1: You're Emotionally Flooded

What this means:
Your heart is racing, you can't think clearly, your stress response is activated.

Physical signs:

Heart rate over 100 bpm
Shallow breathing
Shaking
Feeling overwhelmed
Can't process information

Why you need a break:
When flooded, your prefrontal cortex (logical thinking) shuts down. You can't problem-solve or communicate effectively.

SIGN #2: You're About to Say Something You'll Regret

What this means:
Hurtful words are forming, and you know you'll cross a line.

Warning signs:

Thinking of their worst insecurity
Planning a low blow
Feeling like you want to hurt them
About to bring up something you promised you wouldn't

Why you need a break:
Some things can't be unsaid. Better to pause than destroy trust.

SIGN #3: It's Becoming Personal Instead of Issue-Focused

What this means:
You've stopped discussing the problem and started attacking each other.

What it looks like:

Name-calling
Character attacks
Bringing up the past
"You always/never" statements

Why you need a break:
Personal attacks damage relationships. Stop before more damage is done.

SIGN #4: You're Going in Circles

What this means:
You're repeating the same points with no progress toward resolution.

What it sounds like:

Same arguments for the 5th time
Neither person hearing the other
No new information being shared

Why you need a break:
Continuing won't help. You need fresh perspective.

SIGN #5: One or Both of You Are Exhausted

What this means:
It's late, you're tired, you've been at this for hours.

What it feels like:

Mentally drained
Physically exhausted
Can't focus
Getting more irritable

Why you need a break:
Exhaustion makes everything worse. Resume when rested.

According to research from The Gottman Institute, when heart rate exceeds 100 beats per minute during conflict (emotional flooding), people can't access their problem-solving abilities. Taking a minimum 20-minute break to calm down is essential for productive conversation.

How to Take a Break the RIGHT Way

Here's the step-by-step process for taking productive breaks.

STEP 1: Announce You Need a Break (Don't Just Leave)

Don't:

Storm off without saying anything
Give the silent treatment
Leave the house with no explanation

Do:
"I need to take a break from this conversation. I'm too upset to continue productively right now."

STEP 2: Give a Specific Timeframe

Don't:

"I need space" [indefinitely]
"I can't deal with this right now" [no timeframe]
"Maybe later" [vague]

Do:
"Let's take a 20-minute break and come back to this at 3pm."

Or: "I need a couple hours to process. Can we continue this conversation at 7pm?"

Why this matters:
Specific timeframes prevent the break from feeling like abandonment.

STEP 3: Acknowledge Their Concern

If they're anxious about the break:

"I'm not ending the conversation. I'm just taking a break so we can have a more productive discussion. I'll be back at [time]."

Why this matters:
Reassurance reduces abandonment anxiety.

STEP 4: Actually Calm Down During the Break

Don't:

Rehearse arguments
Build your case
Get angrier
Ruminate on all their faults
Text/call to continue arguing

Do:

Deep breathing
Go for a walk
Listen to calming music
Do something physical (workout, yoga)
Distract yourself with a different activity

Why this matters:
The point is to lower your heart rate and emotional intensity, not to plan your attack.

STEP 5: Return at the Agreed Time

This is NON-NEGOTIABLE.

If you said 20 minutes, return in 20 minutes.

If you need more time:
Before the time is up, communicate: "I need another 20 minutes. Can we resume at 3:30 instead?"

Why this matters:
Following through builds trust that breaks aren't abandonment.

STEP 6: Resume the Conversation Productively

When you return:

"I'm calmer now. Let's talk about this. I want to understand your perspective."

Or: "Okay, I've had time to think. Can we approach this differently?"

Don't:
Return ready to fight more. Return ready to resolve.

STEP 7: If You Can't Resolve It, Schedule Another Time

If you're still stuck after resuming:

"We're still not making progress. Let's table this for now and come back to it tomorrow when we're both fresh. Can we talk about this tomorrow at [time]?"

Why this matters:
Some issues need multiple conversations. That's okay.

Many women discover that understanding what men secretly crave in a relationship reveals why he withdraws during conflict—whether it's emotional flooding or avoidance. This insight—something most women never hear—helps you support his need for space while ensuring the conversation actually gets resolved.

Scripts for Taking Productive Breaks

Let's practice with different scenarios.

SCRIPT #1: You're Getting Too Angry

You feel yourself about to explode:

"I'm getting too angry to continue this conversation productively. I don't want to say something I'll regret. I need 30 minutes to calm down. Let's come back to this at [specific time]. I'm not walking away from resolving this—I just need to cool off first."

SCRIPT #2: They're Getting Too Angry

They're escalating and need a break but won't take one:

"I can see we're both really upset right now. I think we need to take a break and come back to this when we're calmer. Can we pause for 20 minutes and resume at [time]?"

SCRIPT #3: You're Going in Circles

Same points being repeated with no progress:

"We've been discussing this for an hour and we're not making progress. I think we both need some time to think about this differently. Can we take a break and come back to this tonight at [time]?"

SCRIPT #4: It's Late and You're Exhausted

It's midnight and you're both exhausted:

"We're both exhausted and that's making this harder. Let's get some sleep and talk about this in the morning when we're rested. Can we continue this conversation over breakfast at 9am?"

SCRIPT #5: They Want to Chase You During the Break

You've announced a break and they're following you:

"I understand you want to resolve this now, but I need this break to calm down so I can have a better conversation with you. I promise I'll be back in 20 minutes. Please respect that I need this space right now."

SCRIPT #6: You Need Multiple Breaks

You've returned but need another break:

"I'm glad we talked, but I'm still too upset to finish this productively. Can we take another 30-minute break? I'll be back at [time] and we can continue."

Notice the pattern:

Good break scripts:

Explain WHY you need the break
Give specific timeframe
Commit to returning
Reassure it's not abandonment

For couples learning to manage emotional flooding and take productive breaks during conflict, Fighting for Your Marriage: Positive Steps for Preventing Divorce and Building a Lasting Love provides structured timeout protocols that help both partners feel safe during breaks while ensuring issues get resolved.

When Your Partner Needs a Break (And You Don't)

If you're the pursuer and they need space.

What you're feeling:

Abandoned
Anxious
Like the issue will never get resolved
Afraid they're shutting you out
Desperate to finish the conversation NOW

This is understandable.

Especially if:

You have anxious attachment
Past partners used breaks as punishment
You experienced abandonment in childhood

What you need to understand:

Their need for a break isn't about you.

It's about them reaching their emotional capacity.

When someone is flooded:

They CAN'T have a productive conversation
Forcing them to continue makes everything worse
They need time to regulate before they can problem-solve

What to do:

1. Let them take the break
Don't chase, don't demand they stay, don't follow them.

2. Get a specific timeframe
"When will we come back to this?"

3. Take care of yourself during the break
Call a friend, journal, do something calming.

4. Trust they'll return
If they've committed to a time, believe them.

5. Address your abandonment anxiety separately
This is your work to do, not theirs to fix in the moment.

What to say:

"Okay. I understand you need a break. When can we come back to this conversation? I need a specific time so I'm not anxious wondering when we'll resolve it."

Then let them go.

What NOT to do:

❌ Follow them to continue talking
❌ Text/call repeatedly during the break
❌ Punish them for needing space
❌ Bring up that they "always run away"
❌ Make them feel guilty for needing a break

Your anxiety is real and valid.

AND their need for space is real and valid.

Both can be true.

If you struggle with feeling abandoned when he needs space, understanding why some men pull away—and what makes them come back stronger can help you see that his withdrawal during heated moments isn't rejection—it's how he processes. This surprising insight helps you give him space without falling apart.

When Breaks Don't Work

Sometimes the pattern is broken.

Red flags that breaks are being misused:

🚩 They never return to the conversation
They say "later" but later never comes.

🚩 They use breaks to avoid difficult topics
Any uncomfortable conversation leads to indefinite "breaks."

🚩 No specific timeframe is ever given
"I need space" with no plan to resume.

🚩 The break is actually stonewalling
They're punishing you, not regulating themselves.

🚩 They refuse to respect your need for breaks
They follow you, won't let you have space, corner you.

🚩 Every argument requires multiple days of breaks
Using breaks to drag out conflict indefinitely.

🚩 Issues never get resolved
You take breaks but nothing ever gets addressed.

If this is happening:

You don't have a "taking breaks" problem.

You have a communication problem.

What to do:

1. Call out the pattern
"I've noticed we take breaks during arguments but we never come back to resolve the issue. That's not working."

2. Set new ground rules for breaks
"When we take breaks, we need to commit to a specific return time and actually return."

3. Require couples therapy
"We need help learning how to take productive breaks and actually resolve our conflicts."

If they refuse:

Then you know:

They don't want to resolve issues
They want to avoid difficult conversations
They're using breaks as a weapon
The relationship can't improve

That's when you decide:
Can you live like this? Or is it time to leave?

Creating a Break Agreement Together

Prevent future problems by agreeing on break protocols.

Have this conversation when you're NOT fighting:

"I think we should create an agreement about how we handle breaks during arguments. When either of us needs a break, here's what we should do..."

Your break agreement should include:

1. How to announce the break
"Either person can say 'I need a break' without judgment."

2. Minimum timeframe
"Breaks should be at least 20 minutes (enough to calm down)."

3. Maximum timeframe
"Breaks shouldn't exceed 24 hours without checking in."

4. What happens during breaks
"We don't text/call to continue arguing. We focus on calming down."

5. How to resume
"We return at the agreed time ready to resolve, not ready to fight more."

6. What if more time is needed
"If someone needs more time, they communicate before the break ends."

7. Respecting each other's needs
"The person needing space gets it. The person needing closure gets a timeframe."

Write it down.

Put it somewhere you can both reference it.

When arguments happen:
You already know the protocol.

Example agreement:

"When either of us feels too upset to continue productively, we can call a break. We'll say 'I need a break for [timeframe]' and commit to returning at a specific time. During the break, we won't contact each other to continue arguing. We'll use the time to calm down. When we return, we'll approach the conversation calmly and focus on resolution. If we need more time, we'll communicate that before the break ends."

This removes the ambiguity.

Both of you know what to expect.

Breaks feel safer for everyone.

Your Turn: How Do You Handle Breaks During Arguments?

Do you and your partner take breaks during fights? What's worked? What hasn't? How do you manage anxiety during breaks? Share your experience in the comments!

The Bottom Line

Taking breaks during arguments is healthy and necessary.

But HOW you take them determines everything.

Healthy break:

Announces need for break
Sets specific timeframe
Acknowledges partner's concern
Actually calms down during break
Returns at agreed time
Resumes conversation productively

Unhealthy break (stonewalling):

Storms off without explanation
No timeframe given
No intention to return
Uses break to punish/avoid
Never comes back to resolve
Issues never get addressed

When to take a break:

Emotionally flooded (heart racing, can't think)
About to say something you'll regret
Becoming personal instead of issue-focused
Going in circles
Exhausted

How to take a break:

Announce need (don't just leave)
Give specific timeframe
Acknowledge their concern
Actually calm down during break
Return at agreed time
Resume productively
Schedule another time if needed

If your partner needs a break:

Let them have it
Get a specific timeframe
Take care of yourself during break
Trust they'll return
Don't chase or punish

When breaks don't work:

They never return to conversation
Using breaks to avoid all difficult topics
No timeframes ever given
Actually stonewalling
Won't respect your need for breaks
Issues never resolved

Create a break agreement:

Discuss when you're calm
Agree on protocols
Write it down
Reference when needed

You can take breaks AND resolve issues.

They're not mutually exclusive.

Take the break.

Calm down.

Come back.

Resolve it.

That's how healthy couples do it.

How to Stop Yelling at Each Other