How to Stop Being Defensive When Your Partner Criticizes You

Do you immediately get defensive when your partner criticizes you? Learn why defensiveness destroys relationships, how to hear feedback without shutting down, and how to respond to criticism constructively.

⚠️ Important Relationship Advice Disclaimer: This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered professional relationship counseling, therapy, or mental health advice. Relationship dynamics are highly individual and complex, involving unique personal histories, attachment patterns, mental health considerations, and interpersonal dynamics that require personalized professional guidance. The information provided here does not constitute professional counseling or therapy and should not be relied upon as a substitute for qualified mental health care. If you are experiencing relationship distress, mental health challenges, patterns of unhealthy relationships, or emotional difficulties, please consult with a licensed therapist, relationship counselor, or mental health professional who can provide personalized support tailored to your specific situation. Every relationship situation is unique and may require specialized professional intervention. The strategies discussed here are general in nature and may not be appropriate for all situations, particularly those involving abuse, manipulation, or mental health crises.

💡 Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the blog and allows me to continue providing free relationship advice and resources. I only recommend products, services, and resources that I believe will genuinely help you build healthier relationships and improve your romantic life. Thank you for your support!

Quick Answer:

Defensiveness is when you immediately reject feedback, make excuses, turn it back on your partner, or refuse to take any responsibility—it's one of the "Four Horsemen" that predicts divorce. You get defensive because criticism feels like an attack on your character (not just your behavior), triggers shame, activates your fight-or-flight response, or stems from childhood experiences where criticism meant rejection. To stop being defensive: pause before responding, separate your worth from your behavior (you can make mistakes and still be a good person), listen to understand the concern behind the criticism, ask clarifying questions instead of immediately explaining yourself, take responsibility for your part (even if it's just 5%), and respond with "You're right, I did [thing]. I can see why that hurt you. Here's what I'll do differently." The key is hearing criticism as information about your partner's experience, not a verdict on your character. Not all criticism is fair—but reflexive defensiveness prevents you from determining what's valid and what's not.

The Pattern You Can't Break

Your partner brings something up:

"When you said [thing] to me yesterday, it really hurt my feelings."

And immediately you respond with:

"I didn't mean it that way!"
"You're being too sensitive"
"That's not what happened"
"Oh, so I'm a terrible person now?"
"Well what about when YOU..."
"I was just joking!"
"You always twist my words"
"I can't do anything right"

Now the conversation has derailed.

Instead of addressing their concern, you're fighting about:

Whether you did the thing
Whether they're overreacting
Who's more wrong
Past grievances
Everything EXCEPT the actual issue

And your partner is thinking:

"I can't ever bring anything up without them getting defensive. What's the point? I'll just stop trying."

Meanwhile, you're thinking:

"They're always criticizing me. I can't do anything right. Why are they attacking me?"

Both of you feel:

Unheard
Frustrated
Misunderstood
Hopeless about communication

And nothing ever gets resolved.

Here's what you need to understand:

Defensiveness is killing your relationship.

Not the criticism. Not the conflicts.

Your inability to hear feedback without immediately protecting yourself is destroying your ability to connect, grow, and solve problems together.

What Defensiveness Actually Is

Let's define it clearly.

Defensiveness = Refusing to Accept Any Responsibility

According to the Gottman Institute, defensiveness is one of the "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse"—communication patterns that predict divorce.

What it looks like:

❌ Making excuses:
"I only did that because you..."

❌ Turning it back on them:
"Well what about when you did [thing]?"

❌ Denying it happened:
"That's not what I said" / "That didn't happen"

❌ Playing the victim:
"I guess I'm just a horrible person" / "I can't do anything right"

❌ Minimizing:
"You're overreacting" / "It's not that big of a deal"

❌ Blaming them:
"If you hadn't [thing], I wouldn't have done that"

❌ Changing the subject:
"Oh, so now we're going to talk about this again?"

What Defensiveness Says:

To your partner:

"Your feelings don't matter"
"I'm not willing to take any responsibility"
"It's all your fault"
"Don't bother bringing things up to me"

To yourself:

"I can't handle being wrong"
"Criticism means I'm a bad person"
"My worth depends on being perfect"

Why It's Toxic:

1. Nothing gets resolved
If you won't take any responsibility, problems can't be solved

2. Your partner stops sharing
They learn bringing things up is pointless or causes fights

3. Resentment builds
Unaddressed issues pile up until the relationship implodes

4. You don't grow
You can't improve if you never acknowledge mistakes

5. Trust erodes
Your partner can't trust you to hear them when they're hurt

According to research from Dr. John Gottman, defensiveness is strongly correlated with relationship dissatisfaction and divorce. Couples who exhibit high levels of defensiveness are significantly more likely to separate.

Why You Get Defensive

Understanding why helps you change the pattern.

REASON #1: Criticism Feels Like an Attack on Your Character

What's happening:
They say: "You didn't do the dishes like you promised"
You hear: "You're lazy, irresponsible, and don't care about me"

Why:
You can't separate behavior from identity. A criticism of what you DID feels like a condemnation of who you ARE.

The defensive response:
You protect your character by denying, making excuses, or attacking back.

What you need to learn:
You can make mistakes and still be a fundamentally good person.

REASON #2: Criticism Triggers Shame

What's happening:
Deep down, you believe you're not good enough. Criticism confirms your worst fears about yourself.

Why:
Childhood experiences taught you that making mistakes means you're bad, stupid, or unlovable.

The defensive response:
You reject the criticism to protect yourself from overwhelming shame.

What you need to learn:
Mistakes are normal. They don't define your worth.

REASON #3: Your Nervous System Is Activated

What's happening:
Your brain perceives criticism as a threat. Your body goes into fight-or-flight mode.

Why:
Evolutionarily, social rejection was life-threatening. Your brain can't tell the difference between "You forgot to take out the trash" and "You're being exiled from the tribe."

The defensive response:
You fight (attack back, make excuses) or flight (shut down, change subject).

What you need to learn:
Pause and regulate before responding.

REASON #4: You Grew Up with Harsh Criticism

What's happening:
Criticism in your family was cruel, personal, or shaming. You learned criticism = danger.

Why:
Your childhood criticism was: "You're so stupid" "What's wrong with you?" "I'm so disappointed in you"

Not: "This behavior isn't okay. Let's talk about it."

The defensive response:
You protect yourself the way you had to as a child.

What you need to learn:
Adult relationship feedback is different from childhood attacks (if it's a healthy relationship).

REASON #5: You Actually Feel Guilty

What's happening:
You DID do the thing they're upset about. You feel bad. But guilt is uncomfortable.

Why:
It's easier to defend than to sit with the discomfort of having hurt someone you love.

The defensive response:
Deny, minimize, or blame to avoid the guilt.

What you need to learn:
Guilt is appropriate when you've made a mistake. Sitting with it helps you change.

REASON #6: Their Delivery IS Harsh

What's happening:
They're not just critiquing your behavior—they ARE attacking your character with contempt, name-calling, or absolutes.

Why:
Sometimes defensiveness is warranted because you're actually being unfairly attacked.

The defensive response:
You get defensive because the criticism is genuinely unfair or abusive.

What you need to learn:
Differentiate between fair feedback poorly delivered vs. genuine attacks. Address their delivery, not defend the behavior.

Most people have a mix of these reasons.

Understanding YOUR specific triggers helps you manage them.

Fair Criticism vs. Unfair Attacks

Not all criticism is created equal.

You need to be able to tell the difference.

✅ FAIR CRITICISM:

Focuses on specific behavior:
"When you interrupted me three times during dinner..."

Uses "I feel" statements:
"I felt disrespected when you dismissed my concern"

Addresses the present:
"Right now, I need us to talk about..."

Seeks resolution:
"How can we handle this differently next time?"

Stays calm:
Serious but not cruel tone

Assumes good intent:
"I know you didn't mean to hurt me, but..."

❌ UNFAIR ATTACKS:

Attacks your character:
"You're a selfish, thoughtless person"

Uses absolutes:
"You ALWAYS do this" / "You NEVER think of anyone but yourself"

Brings up the past:
"And remember three years ago when you..."

Name-calling or contempt:
"You're an idiot" / Eye-rolling / Sneering

Yelling or aggression:
Screaming, intimidating, aggressive body language

No interest in resolution:
Just wants to hurt or punish you

The Gray Area:

Fair concern, poor delivery:
They have a legitimate point but are expressing it with anger, frustration, or some unfair language.

What to do:
"I hear that you're upset, and I want to understand your concern. But when you say I 'always' do this or call me [name], I get defensive and we can't solve the problem. Can we talk about the specific issue?"

Address both the legitimate concern AND the unfair delivery.

If you're dealing with genuine attacks, contempt, and abuse:

The problem isn't your defensiveness. The problem is the relationship is toxic.

Defensiveness is appropriate when you're being abused.

This article is about defensiveness to FAIR feedback in HEALTHY relationships.

How to Stop Being Defensive (Step by Step)

Here's the actual process for changing this pattern.

STEP 1: Recognize the Physical Signs

Your body tells you you're getting defensive before your brain does.

Physical signs:

Heart rate increasing
Face getting hot
Chest tightening
Hands clenching
Jaw tensing
Feeling adrenaline surge
Wanting to interrupt or yell

When you notice these:
This is your cue to PAUSE before responding.

STEP 2: Pause and Breathe

Don't respond immediately.

Instead:

Take three deep breaths
Count to 5 in your head
Say "Give me a second to think about that"
Physically unclench your body

Why this works:
You can't think clearly when your nervous system is activated. The pause lets your brain come back online.

STEP 3: Separate Behavior from Identity

Remind yourself:

"They're critiquing something I DID, not who I AM."

Translate in your head:

They said: "You didn't do the dishes"
You hear: "You're a lazy worthless person"
Reality: They're annoyed about dishes, not condemning your entire existence

Practice thinking:
"I did a thing that hurt them. That doesn't make me a terrible person. It makes me human."

STEP 4: Listen to Understand

Don't listen to respond. Listen to understand.

Ask yourself:

What are they actually upset about?
What do they need from me?
What's the hurt behind the criticism?

Resist the urge to:

Formulate your defense while they're talking
Interrupt with explanations
Focus on the parts that are "unfair"

Focus on:
Understanding their experience

STEP 5: Ask Clarifying Questions

Instead of defending, ask questions:

"Help me understand—what specifically bothered you about [thing]?"

"When you say I [did thing], can you give me an example so I understand exactly what you mean?"

"What did you need from me that I didn't provide?"

Why this works:
Questions show you're trying to understand. They also buy you time to regulate and often reveal the real issue beneath the surface complaint.

STEP 6: Acknowledge the Valid Part

Even if you disagree with 95% of what they said, find the 5% that's valid.

Examples:

"You're right, I did forget to call when I was running late."

"I can see how my tone came across as dismissive."

"You're right that I haven't been helping as much with [task]."

This doesn't mean:

Accepting blame for things you didn't do
Agreeing you're a terrible person
Taking 100% responsibility

It means:
Acknowledging the kernel of truth

STEP 7: Take Responsibility

After acknowledging the valid part, own it clearly:

"That was wrong of me. I should have [done differently]."

"I understand why that hurt you."

"That wasn't okay, and I'm sorry."

No "but":

Don't say: "I'm sorry, BUT you..."
Say: "I'm sorry. Period."

If there are extenuating circumstances:
Address them AFTER you've taken responsibility, and only if necessary.

STEP 8: Ask What They Need

After owning your part:

"What do you need from me to make this right?"

"How can I handle this better next time?"

"What would help you feel [heard/respected/valued]?"

This shifts from:
"Defending why I did it"

To:
"How do we solve this together?"

STEP 9: Follow Through

Make a specific commitment and keep it.

"I'll set a phone alarm to remind me to call if I'm running more than 15 minutes late."

"I'll work on my tone when we discuss [topic]."

"I'll make sure to [specific action]."

Then actually do it.

Nothing kills trust faster than:
Apologizing beautifully and then repeating the exact same behavior.

For couples working on breaking defensive patterns and building healthier communication, Fighting for Your Marriage: Positive Steps for Preventing Divorce and Building a Lasting Love offers specific exercises for managing emotional reactivity and responding to feedback constructively.

Scripts for Non-Defensive Responses

Let's practice with real examples.

SCENARIO 1: They criticize something you did

They say:
"You said you'd take care of [task] and you didn't. Now I have to do it and I'm already overwhelmed."

Defensive response:
"I was going to do it! You're always on my case about everything!"

Non-defensive response:
"You're right, I said I'd do that and I dropped the ball. I'm sorry you're stuck dealing with it now. Let me take care of it right now, or if it's already done, I'll make sure I follow through next time."

SCENARIO 2: They criticize your tone or attitude

They say:
"The way you talked to me just now was really dismissive and hurtful."

Defensive response:
"I didn't say anything wrong! You're being too sensitive!"

Non-defensive response:
"I didn't realize my tone came across that way, but if you felt dismissed, that matters. I'm sorry. What did I say that felt dismissive? I want to understand so I can communicate better."

SCENARIO 3: They bring up a pattern

They say:
"You've been on your phone constantly when we're together. I feel like you're not present with me."

Defensive response:
"Oh my god, I can't even relax without you complaining!"

Non-defensive response:
"You're right, I have been on my phone a lot. That's not okay. You deserve my attention when we're spending time together. I'm going to put it away right now. Can we agree on times when it's okay to check it and times when it's not?"

SCENARIO 4: They criticize something sensitive

They say:
"You promised you'd work on [sensitive issue like sex drive, helping more, anger, whatever], but nothing has changed."

Defensive response:
"I HAVE been trying! You don't appreciate anything I do!"

Non-defensive response:
"You're right that I haven't made as much progress as I said I would. I know that's frustrating. I think I need more support—maybe therapy or [specific resource]. This is hard for me, but it's clearly important to you, which makes it important to me. Let's figure out a plan together."

SCENARIO 5: They're upset about something you forgot

They say:
"You forgot [important thing] again. This is the third time."

Defensive response:
"I have a lot on my mind! You're not perfect either!"

Non-defensive response:
"You're absolutely right. This is the third time, and that's not acceptable. Clearly just 'trying to remember' isn't working. I'm going to [set phone reminders / put it on shared calendar / whatever specific solution]. I'm sorry I've been unreliable about this."

Notice the pattern:

Non-defensive responses:

Acknowledge the valid part immediately
Apologize without excuses
Take ownership
Suggest concrete solutions
Focus on their experience, not your intentions

When to Address Their Delivery

Sometimes the criticism is valid but the delivery is terrible.

Signs Their Delivery Is the Problem:

They're yelling or name-calling
Using absolutes ("you always" / "you never")
Attacking your character, not your behavior
Bringing up past issues
Being contemptuous or cruel

How to Address It:

Step 1: Acknowledge their concern
"I hear that you're upset about [issue]."

Step 2: Address the delivery
"But when you [yell / call me names / say I 'always' do this], I can't hear your actual concern. I get defensive and we can't solve the problem."

Step 3: Ask for what you need
"Can we talk about [the actual issue] without [the problematic delivery]? I do want to understand and work on this."

Script:

They say: "You NEVER help around here! You're so lazy and selfish!"

You say:
"I hear that you're frustrated about housework distribution, and that's a fair conversation to have. But when you call me lazy and selfish, I can't engage productively. Can we talk about the actual division of labor without the name-calling?"

If they won't stop the harsh delivery:

"I want to discuss this with you, but not while you're attacking my character. I'm going to take a break. Let's come back to this when we can both be respectful."

Then follow through:
Leave the room. Come back when they can discuss respectfully.

Don't use their poor delivery as an excuse to avoid the legitimate issue.

Address both:

Their valid concern
Their problematic delivery

Healing the Shame That Drives Defensiveness

Long-term change requires addressing the root cause.

If defensiveness comes from shame:

You need to work on:

1. Separating worth from performance
Your value as a person isn't determined by how perfectly you perform

2. Accepting imperfection
Everyone makes mistakes. That's being human, not being defective.

3. Challenging negative self-talk
Notice when you're telling yourself "I'm terrible" instead of "I made a mistake"

4. Building self-compassion
Talk to yourself the way you'd talk to a friend who messed up

Therapy helps:

Consider:

Individual therapy to address shame roots
Childhood wounds that make criticism feel life-threatening
Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for thought patterns
EMDR if trauma is involved

Self-work you can do:

Journal prompts:

"What did criticism mean in my childhood?"
"What do I believe about myself when I make mistakes?"
"Can I think of someone I love who makes mistakes? Does that make them less valuable?"

Practice self-compassion:
When you mess up: "This is hard. Everyone struggles with this. I'm doing my best and I can learn from this."

Challenge all-or-nothing thinking:
"Making this mistake doesn't make me a failure. It makes me someone learning and growing."

The less shame you carry, the less defensive you'll be.

Because criticism won't feel life-threatening anymore.

When Defensiveness Is Appropriate

Sometimes being defensive is the right response.

Be defensive when:

🚩 You're being gaslit
They're denying reality or making you question your sanity

🚩 You're being verbally abused
Constant name-calling, cruelty, contempt

🚩 They're always criticizing
Nothing you do is ever good enough

🚩 They're hypocritical
They criticize you for things they do constantly

🚩 They're using criticism to control you
The goal isn't improvement—it's making you feel small

🚩 The relationship is emotionally abusive
Criticism is just one of many toxic patterns

In these cases:

The problem isn't your defensiveness.

The problem is you're in a toxic or abusive relationship.

What to do:

Individual therapy
Assess if the relationship is salvageable
Consider leaving
Don't work on "being less defensive" if you're being abused

Defensiveness in response to abuse is a healthy boundary.

Don't pathologize normal self-protection.

Your Turn: How Have You Overcome Defensiveness?

Have you struggled with defensiveness? What helped you change? What techniques work for you? How did your partner support you in working on this? Share your experience in the comments!

The Bottom Line

Defensiveness destroys relationships.

It's one of the "Four Horsemen" that predicts divorce.

Not because you shouldn't defend yourself ever.

But because reflexive defensiveness prevents:

Resolution
Growth
Connection
Trust
Intimacy

You get defensive because:

Criticism feels like an attack on who you are
You carry shame from childhood
Your nervous system perceives threat
You feel guilty and want to avoid discomfort
You genuinely are being unfairly attacked

To stop being defensive:

Pause before responding
Separate behavior from identity
Listen to understand their concern
Ask clarifying questions
Acknowledge the valid part
Take responsibility
Commit to change
Follow through

The goal isn't to accept all criticism blindly.

The goal is to hear feedback without immediately protecting yourself.

When you can:

Hear "you hurt me" without hearing "you're a terrible person"
Take responsibility for your mistakes without feeling worthless
Acknowledge valid criticism without making excuses

Then you can:

Solve problems together
Grow as a person
Build deeper intimacy
Earn trust
Create lasting love

Defensiveness keeps you stuck.

Openness sets you free.

The strongest people can hear "you hurt me" and say "I'm sorry."

The weakest people can't admit any fault ever.

Which one do you want to be?

How to Set Boundaries Without Starting a Fight