Prenups: How to Bring It Up Without Insulting Your Partner

Want a prenup but scared to ask? Learn why prenups protect both people, how to start the conversation without implying divorce, and what to include in a fair prenuptial agreement.

⚠️ Important Relationship Advice Disclaimer: This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered professional relationship counseling, therapy, or mental health advice. Relationship dynamics are highly individual and complex, involving unique personal histories, attachment patterns, mental health considerations, and interpersonal dynamics that require personalized professional guidance. The information provided here does not constitute professional counseling or therapy and should not be relied upon as a substitute for qualified mental health care. If you are experiencing relationship distress, mental health challenges, patterns of unhealthy relationships, or emotional difficulties, please consult with a licensed therapist, relationship counselor, or mental health professional who can provide personalized support tailored to your specific situation. Every relationship situation is unique and may require specialized professional intervention. The strategies discussed here are general in nature and may not be appropriate for all situations, particularly those involving abuse, manipulation, or mental health crises.

💡 Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the blog and allows me to continue providing free relationship advice and resources. I only recommend products, services, and resources that I believe will genuinely help you build healthier relationships and improve your romantic life. Thank you for your support!

Quick Answer:

How to bring up a prenup without insulting your partner: Frame it as protecting both of you, not planning for divorce. Say "I love you and I'm excited to marry you, AND I think we should have a prenup to make sure we're both protected and clear about expectations. This isn't about not trusting you—it's about making sure we start marriage on the same page financially." Then explain what prenups actually do: clarify separate vs. marital property, protect inheritances and family assets, outline financial responsibilities, and prevent ugly court battles if the worst happens. The conversation works best when you emphasize partnership ("let's do this together"), use "we" language, acknowledge their feelings, and show you've researched what's fair for both people. Prenups aren't unromantic—they're responsible. And if your partner refuses to even discuss it, that's a red flag about communication and willingness to protect your interests.

The Conversation You're Terrified to Have

You're getting married. You're excited. You're in love.

And you want a prenup.

But you're terrified to bring it up because:

It feels like you're planning for divorce before you're even married
You don't want them to think you don't trust them
You're afraid they'll be hurt or offended
You don't want to seem unromantic or cynical
You're worried they'll say no and it'll become a huge fight
You don't know how to frame it without sounding like a jerk

So you're debating:

Should I just skip it to avoid the fight?
Will they think I don't believe in our marriage?
Am I being paranoid or practical?
Is wanting a prenup a sign I shouldn't get married?

Here's the truth you need to hear:

Wanting a prenup doesn't mean you expect to get divorced. It means you're an adult who understands that life is unpredictable, and clear agreements prevent ugly conflicts.

And if your partner interprets "I want to protect both of us" as "I don't love you," that's a communication problem you need to address before marriage—not avoid.

Let's talk about how to have this conversation like mature adults planning a life together.

What Prenups Actually Do (And Don't Do)

First, let's clear up misconceptions.

✅ What Prenups CAN Do:

1. Protect Pre-Marriage Assets

Property you owned before marriage stays yours
Businesses you started before marriage
Inheritances from your family
Trust funds or family money
Investments you made before marriage

2. Clarify Separate vs. Marital Property

Which assets are individual vs. shared
How you'll handle income during marriage
What happens to jointly purchased items
How you'll treat gifts and inheritances

3. Outline Financial Responsibilities

Who pays which debts
How you'll manage joint accounts
Responsibilities for household expenses
Student loan or credit card debt responsibility

4. Protect Business Interests

Keeps your business partner from becoming your spouse's business partner in divorce
Protects business assets
Prevents spouse from claiming stake in your company

5. Protect Children from Previous Relationships

Ensures inheritance goes to your children
Protects assets meant for kids
Clarifies estate planning

6. Avoid Lengthy Divorce Battles

Decisions already made about property division
Reduces legal fees and court time
Removes emotional decision-making from already painful process
Makes divorce faster and less destructive (if it happens)

7. Outline Spousal Support (Alimony)

Can limit or specify alimony terms
Prevents surprises if marriage ends
Protects higher earner from unlimited support obligations

❌ What Prenups CANNOT Do:

Cannot dictate child custody or child support

Courts decide based on child's best interest, not prenup
Child support is a right of the child, not negotiable

Cannot include illegal provisions

Can't waive right to alimony entirely in some states
Can't include anything illegal or unconscionable

Cannot be signed under duress

Springing it on your partner days before wedding = likely invalid
Both parties need time to review and get their own lawyers

Cannot be completely one-sided

Courts can throw out "unconscionable" prenups
Must be somewhat fair to both parties

According to the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, prenuptial agreements have increased 62% in recent years, with millennials driving the trend as they marry later with established assets and careers.

Why Smart People Get Prenups

Let's normalize this. Prenups aren't cynical—they're practical.

Reason #1: You're Marrying Later with Established Assets

The situation:

You're 35, not 22
You have retirement savings, property, investments
You've built a career and business
You have assets worth protecting

Why prenup makes sense:
You both bring substantial assets to the marriage. Clarity about what's separate vs. shared prevents confusion and conflict.

Reason #2: Significant Income/Asset Disparity

The situation:

One person makes $200K, the other makes $50K
One person has family wealth, the other doesn't
One person owns property, the other rents

Why prenup makes sense:
Protects both people. Higher earner protects assets. Lower earner gets clarity about what they're entitled to.

Reason #3: Business Ownership

The situation:

You own a business
You have business partners
Your business is your livelihood

Why prenup makes sense:
Divorce could force you to sell your business to split assets. Prenup keeps business separate and protects your livelihood and your partners.

Reason #4: Second Marriage / Blended Family

The situation:

You have kids from previous marriage
You want to ensure inheritance goes to your children
You're protecting assets for your kids' future

Why prenup makes sense:
Without prenup, new spouse could claim assets meant for your children. Prenup ensures your kids are protected.

Reason #5: Family Money/Inheritance

The situation:

Your family has wealth you'll inherit
You received inheritance or trust fund
Family business or property

Why prenup makes sense:
Keeps family assets separate. Protects your family's generational wealth. Prevents in-law drama about money.

Reason #6: Debt Protection

The situation:

Your partner has significant debt
You're debt-free and want to stay that way
One person has student loans, medical debt, credit card debt

Why prenup makes sense:
Ensures you're not legally responsible for debt you didn't create. Protects your credit and financial health.

Reason #7: You've Seen Ugly Divorces

The situation:

Your parents had a nightmare divorce
You watched friends lose everything in divorce
You know how nasty it can get

Why prenup makes sense:
Prevents that trauma. If you do divorce, at least the financial part is already settled. Reduces conflict when emotions are high.

Prenups aren't pessimistic. They're realistic.

50% of marriages end in divorce. That's a fact. Planning for that possibility doesn't make it more likely—it just makes you smart.

If you're looking for evidence-based strategies for building a strong marriage from the start, Fighting for Your Marriage: Positive Steps for Preventing Divorce and Building a Lasting Love offers research-backed communication techniques that complement the legal protections of a prenup.

The Conversation: How to Bring It Up

Okay, you're convinced you need a prenup. Now how do you tell your partner?

Step 1: Choose Your Timing Wisely

GOOD timing:

After engagement but well before wedding (6+ months minimum)
During a calm, private conversation
When you're both rested and not stressed
After discussing other wedding/marriage planning logistics

BAD timing:

During a fight
Days or weeks before wedding
In front of friends or family
Via text or email (have this in person)

Step 2: Frame It as Protecting Both of You

Script for opening the conversation:

"Hey, I want to talk to you about something related to our marriage. I know this might seem unromantic, but I think we should consider a prenuptial agreement.

Before you react, let me explain what I mean. This isn't about not trusting you or planning for divorce. It's about making sure we're both protected and we start our marriage with total clarity about finances.

I've been reading about prenups, and they actually protect both of us. They clarify what's separate vs. shared property, they protect us from each other's debts, and if the worst ever happened, they prevent us from having an ugly court battle.

I love you. I'm excited to marry you. And I want to make sure we're doing this in a way that's fair and clear for both of us. Can we talk about this?"

Step 3: Address Their Likely Concerns

They might say: "Don't you trust me?"

Your response:
"This has nothing to do with trust. I trust you completely. But life is unpredictable. People change. Situations change. A prenup isn't about us not trusting each other now—it's about making sure we're both protected no matter what happens. It's the responsible thing to do."

They might say: "You're already planning our divorce!"

Your response:
"I'm not planning our divorce—I'm planning our marriage. Part of that is making sure we have clear financial agreements. We buy car insurance not because we plan to crash, but because we're responsible adults. Same concept. A prenup is just insurance for our finances."

They might say: "That's so unromantic."

Your response:
"You know what's really unromantic? A bitter divorce where we fight over every piece of furniture and drain our savings on lawyers. Having clarity now, while we love each other and want the best for each other, is actually the most loving thing we can do. We're making these decisions from a place of respect and care, not anger and resentment."

They might say: "I don't have anything anyway, so this is just to protect you."

Your response:
"Actually, a prenup protects you too. It can protect you from my debts. It can ensure you get certain things if we divorce. It gives you clarity about what you're entitled to. This isn't one-sided—we'll both have lawyers making sure the agreement is fair to both of us."

They might say: "My family will think you don't love me."

Your response:
"This is between us, not your family. We're adults making adult decisions about our financial future. We don't need their permission. And honestly, smart people will understand that this is responsible planning, not a lack of love."

Step 4: Emphasize Partnership

Use "we" language:

"Let's figure this out together"
"We'll both have lawyers to make sure it's fair"
"We can decide together what goes in it"
"This is us protecting our future"

Avoid "you" language:

Not: "I need to protect myself from you"
Not: "You need to sign this"
Not: "I'm requiring this"

Step 5: Offer to Educate Yourself Together

Say:
"I know neither of us is an expert on this. How about we both do some research and talk to a lawyer together? That way we're making informed decisions, not just going on assumptions or fear."

Suggest:

Reading articles together
Consulting with a family law attorney together (initial consultation)
Talking to couples who have prenups
Reviewing sample prenups to understand what's typical

What to Include in Your Prenup

If you both agree to move forward, here's what you'll discuss with your lawyers:

Standard Prenup Provisions:

1. Separate Property

Property owned before marriage stays separate
Gifts and inheritances remain separate
Specific items designated as separate (family heirlooms, etc.)

2. Marital Property

How jointly purchased property is handled
Income earned during marriage
How you'll handle joint accounts
Real estate purchased together

3. Debt Responsibility

Pre-marital debt stays with person who incurred it
How jointly incurred debt is split
Who's responsible for what during marriage

4. Spousal Support (Alimony)

Whether there will be alimony
How much and for how long
Conditions under which it's paid
Waiver of alimony (if state allows)

5. Death and Estate Planning

What happens if one spouse dies
Inheritance rights
Life insurance provisions
Estate distribution

6. Business Interests

Business stays separate property
Spouse has no claim to business
How business income is treated

7. Retirement Accounts

Are they separate or marital property?
How are they divided if divorce happens?
Who gets what accounts?

Things You CANNOT Include:

❌ Child custody arrangements
❌ Child support amounts
❌ Anything illegal
❌ Non-financial lifestyle clauses (who does dishes, frequency of sex, etc.) - courts won't enforce these
❌ Provisions that violate public policy

Making It Fair:

Both people should:

Have their own lawyer (this is essential)
Fully disclose all assets and debts
Have time to review and consider (no rushed signing)
Understand what they're signing
Feel the agreement is reasonably fair

Red flags for unfair prenups:

Signed days before wedding (duress)
One person didn't have a lawyer
One person didn't disclose all assets
So one-sided it's unconscionable
Forced or coerced into signing

According to Nolo's Legal Encyclopedia, prenuptial agreements must meet specific legal requirements to be enforceable, including full financial disclosure from both parties and independent legal representation.

The Process: Step-by-Step

Here's how actually getting a prenup works:

Step 1: Have the Initial Conversation (3-12 months before wedding)

Use the scripts above. Get on the same page about wanting a prenup.

Step 2: Full Financial Disclosure (2-3 months before wedding)

Both people create lists of:

All assets (property, accounts, investments, business interests)
All debts (student loans, credit cards, mortgages)
Income sources
Retirement accounts
Inheritances or expected inheritances

Be 100% transparent. Hiding assets can invalidate the whole prenup.

Step 3: Each Person Hires Their Own Lawyer (2-3 months before wedding)

This is non-negotiable.

You CANNOT use the same lawyer. That's a conflict of interest and can invalidate the prenup.

Find:

Family law attorney with prenup experience
Someone who represents YOUR interests
Not your wedding planner's cousin who "does some legal stuff"

Cost:
Expect $1,500-$5,000+ per person depending on complexity and location.

Step 4: Negotiate Terms (1-2 months before wedding)

Your lawyers will draft the agreement based on what you both want.

There will be back-and-forth:

Your lawyer proposes terms protecting you
Their lawyer proposes terms protecting them
You negotiate until it's fair to both

This takes time. Don't rush it.

Step 5: Review and Revise (1 month before wedding minimum)

Both of you review the final agreement with your lawyers.

Your lawyer should explain:

What you're agreeing to
What you're giving up
Whether they think it's fair
Any concerns they have

Make sure you understand every provision.

Step 6: Sign the Agreement (Minimum 30 days before wedding)

Both people sign in front of notary.

Requirements for valid prenup:

✓ In writing
✓ Signed voluntarily (no duress)
✓ Full disclosure of assets/debts
✓ Both had lawyers (or waived right to lawyer in writing)
✓ Signed well before wedding (not last minute)
✓ Not unconscionable (grossly unfair)

Keep copies:

With your lawyer
In safe deposit box
With estate planning documents

Step 7: Review After Major Life Events

Consider updating prenup after:

Having children
Starting a business
Receiving large inheritance
Significant income change
Buying property together

You can't change a prenup without both agreeing to a post-nuptial agreement.

The whole process takes 2-6 months typically.

Don't wait until month before wedding to start this.

When Your Partner Says No

What if you bring it up and they absolutely refuse?

Their Reasons and Your Responses:

"I find it offensive."

Consider:
Why do they find it offensive? Do they think you don't trust them? Help them understand this is standard financial planning, not a personal attack.

If they still refuse:
This is a communication problem. If you can't discuss financial protection before marriage, how will you handle actual financial conflicts during marriage?

"It means you expect us to fail."

Response:
"I expect us to succeed. But I'm also a realist. I don't expect to get in a car accident, but I have car insurance. I don't expect our house to burn down, but I have homeowner's insurance. This is the same concept—responsible planning for unpredictable life."

"My family would never accept it."

Response:
"This isn't your family's marriage. This is ours. We're adults making decisions about our financial future. We don't need their approval."

If they still defer to family:
Red flag. They're not ready to be a partner if they can't make decisions independent of their family.

"If you loved me, you wouldn't need this."

Response:
"I love you completely. That's why I want to marry you. This has nothing to do with love and everything to do with being responsible adults. Love and legal protection aren't mutually exclusive."

If they continue conflating love with financial risk:
This is emotional manipulation. Refusing to protect your assets isn't proof of love—it's proof of poor judgment.

🚩 Red Flags If They Refuse:

❌ They get angry or hostile about even discussing it
❌ They accuse you of not loving them
❌ They refuse to hear your reasons
❌ They threaten to call off wedding if you insist
❌ They won't compromise at all
❌ They try to rush you into marriage before you can get prenup

If you see these red flags:

This isn't about the prenup anymore. This is about:

Their inability to have difficult conversations
Their unwillingness to protect your interests
Their use of emotional manipulation
Their lack of respect for your financial security

You need couples counseling before marriage, not just a prenup.

And honestly, if they absolutely refuse any prenup and you have significant assets to protect, you need to seriously reconsider whether marriage to this person is wise. For couples struggling with this type of fundamental disagreement, Fighting for Your Marriage: Positive Steps for Preventing Divorce and Building a Lasting Love offers communication frameworks that can help you navigate these difficult conversations.

Alternative: Postnuptial Agreement

What if you're already married without a prenup?

You can create a postnuptial agreement (postnup).

What's a Postnup?

Same as prenup, but signed after marriage.

Covers:

Same topics as prenup
Clarifies separate vs. marital property
Outlines spousal support
Protects business interests
Addresses debt responsibility

Why get one:

You didn't have prenup before marriage
Circumstances changed significantly (inheritance, business success)
You're reconciling after separation
One person has become financially irresponsible
You want clarity after financial betrayal

Is It Harder to Enforce?

Sometimes.

Courts scrutinize postnups more closely because:

There's a fiduciary duty between spouses
Higher risk of coercion
Might be signed during marital stress

To make postnup valid:

Full disclosure of assets
Both have independent lawyers
Not signed under duress
Fair to both parties
Consideration (something of value exchanged)

When to Consider Postnup:

✓ After receiving large inheritance
✓ Starting a new business
✓ One person has become irresponsible with money
✓ Reconciling after infidelity or separation
✓ Blending finances after keeping them separate
✓ Planning for aging parents or estate issues

Process is similar to prenup:

Both hire lawyers
Full disclosure
Negotiation
Signing

Better late than never.

If you didn't get a prenup but wish you had, a postnup can provide similar protection.

Your Turn: Do You Have a Prenup?

Did you get a prenup? How did you bring it up? How did your partner react? Would you recommend it to others? Or do you regret not getting one? Share your experience in the comments—people need to hear real stories about this!

The Bottom Line

Prenups are not unromantic.

They're responsible.

You're about to make a legal contract called marriage. Part of that contract should clarify what happens if the marriage ends.

That's not pessimistic. That's realistic.

50% of marriages fail. You buy insurance for your car, your house, your health. Why wouldn't you "insure" your financial future?

A prenup doesn't mean you expect to get divorced.

It means:

You're both adults with assets worth protecting
You understand that clarity prevents conflict
You want to make decisions now, while you love each other, not later when you might hate each other
You're being realistic about life's unpredictability
You respect both your interests and theirs

If your partner refuses to even discuss a prenup:

That's not a prenup problem. That's a communication problem.

You're about to legally and financially bind yourself to this person for life.

If you can't have difficult conversations about money and protection now, how will you handle:

Disagreements about buying a house?
Conflicts about children's education expenses?
Different investment philosophies?
Career changes that affect income?
Family members asking for money?

Marriage requires difficult conversations.

Prenups are practice for all the other hard talks you'll need to have.

Get the prenup.

Protect yourself.

And if your partner truly loves you and has your best interests at heart, they'll understand that this protects both of you.

Planning for the worst while hoping for the best isn't cynical.

It's wisdom.

When Your Partner Hides Purchases and Lies About Spending