My Partner Wants to Open Our Relationship

Your partner just asked to open your relationship, and you're panicking. Learn what this request really means, how to have the conversation, and how to decide if this is right for you—without judgment either way.

⚠️ Important Relationship Advice Disclaimer: This content is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be considered professional relationship counseling, therapy, or mental health advice. Relationship dynamics are highly individual and complex, involving unique personal histories, attachment patterns, mental health considerations, and interpersonal dynamics that require personalized professional guidance. The information provided here does not constitute professional counseling or therapy and should not be relied upon as a substitute for qualified mental health care. If you are experiencing relationship distress, mental health challenges, patterns of unhealthy relationships, or emotional difficulties, please consult with a licensed therapist, relationship counselor, or mental health professional who can provide personalized support tailored to your specific situation. Every relationship situation is unique and may require specialized professional intervention. The strategies discussed here are general in nature and may not be appropriate for all situations, particularly those involving abuse, manipulation, or mental health crises.

💡 Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase or sign up for a service, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the blog and allows me to continue providing free relationship advice and resources. I only recommend products, services, and resources that I believe will genuinely help you build healthier relationships and improve your romantic life. Thank you for your support!

Quick Answer:

If your partner wants to open your relationship: This is not a decision you need to make immediately. Take time to understand what they're actually asking for, why they want it, and most importantly—how YOU feel about it. Opening a relationship doesn't save struggling relationships and works only when both people genuinely want it, not when one person is pressuring the other. You're not closed-minded for saying no. You're not a bad partner for being monogamous. And if this is a deal-breaker for either of you, that's valid information about compatibility.

The Conversation That Changes Everything

They just asked. Maybe it was:

"I've been thinking... what would you think about opening our relationship?"

Or maybe:

"I don't think monogamy is natural. I think we should explore being with other people."

Or even:

"I met someone I'm attracted to, and I want to pursue it. Can we make this work?"

And now your world is spinning.

Your mind is racing with questions:

"Does this mean they don't want me anymore?"
"Are they already cheating?"
"Am I not enough?"
"Is this some kind of test?"
"What the hell do I even say to this?"

Here's what you need to know right now, in this moment of panic:

You don't have to answer immediately. This is a huge ask that deserves time and thought.
Your immediate "no" is valid. You're not required to consider this just because they asked.
This doesn't automatically mean your relationship is over. But it might be, and that's okay.
Your feelings—whatever they are—are valid. Devastated? Curious? Angry? Intrigued? All normal.

This article isn't here to convince you to say yes OR no.

It's here to help you navigate one of the most difficult conversations you'll ever have in a relationship—and make a decision that's right for YOU.

What "Opening the Relationship" Actually Means

First, let's get clear on what they might be asking for:

Option 1: Polyamory

What it is: Multiple romantic AND emotional relationships simultaneously

What it looks like:

Your partner wants to date other people and develop feelings for them
Everyone involved knows about everyone else
There can be multiple "primary" or equal partners

The commitment level: High emotional investment in multiple people

Option 2: Open Relationship (Sexual Non-Monogamy)

What it is: Permission to have sex with other people, but romantic exclusivity remains

What it looks like:

Casual sex with others is allowed
No emotional relationships or "dating" other people
Your primary relationship is still the priority

The commitment level: Physical freedom, emotional exclusivity

Option 3: Swinging

What it is: Couples engaging with other couples or individuals sexually, together

What it looks like:

You do this AS A COUPLE, not separately
Typically at parties, clubs, or arranged meetups
Both people are present and participating

The commitment level: Shared sexual exploration, not individual freedom

Option 4: Don't Ask, Don't Tell

What it is: Each person can do what they want, but you don't discuss it

What it looks like:

What happens outside the relationship stays outside
No details shared
Plausible deniability

The commitment level: Freedom with willful ignorance (often doesn't work)

Option 5: One-Sided Open Relationship

What it is: One person gets to see other people, the other doesn't

What it looks like:

They want freedom while you remain monogamous
Often framed as "you could too if you wanted"
But the dynamic is clearly unequal

The commitment level: Unbalanced (rarely works long-term)

Ask your partner: "Which of these are you actually suggesting? What specifically do you want this to look like?"

Because "open our relationship" can mean a thousand different things, and you need to know EXACTLY what they're asking for.

Why They Might Be Asking (And What It Actually Means)

Let's explore the possible motivations—some innocent, some not:

Reason #1: They Genuinely Believe They're Polyamorous

What this means:

They've realized (or always known) they can love multiple people at once
Monogamy feels restrictive and unnatural to them
This isn't about YOU being insufficient—it's about their orientation

Is this fixable? Maybe. If you're open to exploring and you discover you're poly too. But if you're monogamous? You're incompatible.

Red flags to watch for:

If they're framing it as "evolved" or "more mature" than monogamy
If they're making you feel backwards for being monogamous

Reason #2: They Want Sexual Variety

What this means:

They're bored sexually
They want to explore fantasies or experiences you can't or won't provide
They still love you but want physical diversity

Is this fixable? Depends. Can you work on sexual variety WITHIN your relationship first? Have you tried everything before jumping to opening it?

Red flags to watch for:

If they haven't tried to improve your sex life first
If this is about a SPECIFIC person they want to pursue

Reason #3: They're Already Cheating (Or Want Permission to Cheat)

What this means:

They've met someone or are having an affair
They want retroactive permission
They're trying to avoid guilt by making it "ethical"

Is this fixable? This isn't about opening the relationship—it's about betrayal. Different conversation entirely.

Red flags to watch for:

They have someone specific in mind
The timing is suspicious (after they've been distant or secretive)
They're pushing for an immediate answer

Reason #4: They're Trying to Save a Dying Relationship

What this means:

Your relationship is struggling
They think adding other people will bring excitement back
They're avoiding dealing with actual problems

Is this fixable? NO. Opening a relationship never fixes a broken one. It only exposes the cracks faster.

Red flags to watch for:

You've been having problems and THIS is their solution
They frame it as "maybe this will help us reconnect"

Reason #5: They're Testing Your Love/Commitment

What this means:

They want to see if you'll agree to keep them
It's a manipulation tactic
They might not even really want to open the relationship

Is this fixable? This is toxic. Run.

Red flags to watch for:

"If you really loved me, you'd do this for me"
Ultimatums
Using your "no" against you

Reason #6: They Genuinely Want to Explore (And They're Honest About It)

What this means:

They're curious about non-monogamy
They've been reading about it and think it might work for them
They're bringing it to you as a discussion, not an ultimatum

Is this fixable? This is the ONLY healthy version of this ask. You can have an honest conversation about whether this works for both of you.

Green flags to look for:

They respect that this is a mutual decision
They're willing to do research together
They make it clear you can say no
They're not pressuring you

The Questions You Need to Ask Them

Before you make ANY decision, you need answers to these questions:

Question #1: Why Now?

"What made you start thinking about this? Has something changed?"

What you're looking for:

Is there a specific person?
Have they been unhappy?
Is this a longstanding feeling or sudden?

Question #2: What Specifically Do You Want?

"When you say 'open relationship,' what exactly do you mean? What would this look like in practice?"

What you're looking for:

Polyamory vs. casual sex vs. swinging
How often, with whom, under what circumstances
Their actual vision, not vague ideas

Question #3: What Are You Missing?

"Is there something you're not getting from our relationship? Can we work on that together first?"

What you're looking for:

Is this about an unmet need you could address?
Or is this about wanting multiple partners regardless of your relationship health?

Question #4: What If I Say No?

"If I'm not comfortable with this, what happens to us?"

What you're looking for:

Are they willing to stay monogamous?
Or is this a deal-breaker for them?
This reveals if it's a request or an ultimatum

Question #5: How Long Have You Been Thinking About This?

"How long have you felt this way? Have you been planning this?"

What you're looking for:

If it's been years, it's likely a fundamental orientation
If it's recent, what triggered it?

Question #6: Have You Already Done Anything?

"Have you acted on this already? Is there someone specific you have in mind?"

What you're looking for:

Honesty about whether this is retroactive permission
If they hesitate or lie, that's your answer

How to Figure Out if YOU Could Ever Be Okay With This

Now the hard part: What do YOU actually want?

Step 1: Separate Your Panic from Your Actual Feelings

Right now, you might feel:

Shock
Betrayal
Inadequacy
Fear of losing them

These are immediate reactions. They're valid. But they're not necessarily your final answer.

Give yourself time to process the initial shock before making a decision.

Step 2: Ask Yourself These Honest Questions

Question 1: Have I ever been curious about non-monogamy?

Be honest. Have you ever wondered? Or is this completely foreign and unappealing?

Question 2: Am I jealous by nature?

Could you handle your partner being intimate with someone else? Or would it destroy you?

Question 3: Why am I monogamous?

Is it because:

That's what society expects?
That's what I genuinely want?
I've never questioned it?
I can't imagine sharing my partner?

Question 4: Am I considering this to keep them, or because I'm genuinely interested?

This is the most important question.

If you're only saying yes because you're afraid they'll leave otherwise—don't do it.

Step 3: Do Your Own Research

Before you decide, educate yourself:

Read books on ethical non-monogamy
Listen to podcasts from people in open relationships
Join online forums (read, don't post yet)
Understand what you'd actually be agreeing to

You might discover:

This could actually work for you
OR this confirms it's absolutely not for you

Both are valid discoveries.

Step 4: Imagine It in Detail

Don't think abstractly. Get specific:

Your partner goes on a date with someone else tonight. How do you feel?
Your partner has sex with someone else. How do you feel?
Your partner develops feelings for someone else. How do you feel?
Your partner spends the weekend with someone else. How do you feel?

If you're feeling:

Mild discomfort but curiosity: Maybe you could explore this
Absolute devastation and nausea: This isn't for you
"Maybe I could handle it if [specific conditions]": Keep thinking through what those conditions are

If You're Considering Saying Yes: The Rules You MUST Establish

Opening a relationship without clear agreements is a recipe for disaster.

If—and only if—you're both genuinely interested, here are non-negotiable foundations:

Rule #1: Complete Honesty and Communication

What this means:

No secrets
Full disclosure before anything happens with someone new
Regular check-ins about how you're both feeling
If something feels off, you talk about it immediately

Rule #2: Veto Power (At Least Initially)

What this means:

Either person can say "I'm not comfortable with [specific person/situation]"
That veto is respected without argument
You're both still prioritizing each other's comfort

Rule #3: Safer Sex Non-Negotiable

What this means:

Condoms/barriers with all outside partners
Regular STI testing
Full disclosure of any risks
Your health is not negotiable

Rule #4: Time and Energy Boundaries

What this means:

Your primary relationship gets priority
Outside relationships can't interfere with your quality time
Date nights, weekends, important events are sacred
You're not neglecting each other for new people

Rule #5: The Ability to Close It Again

What this means:

If either person is struggling, you can pause or close the relationship
This isn't forever unless it works for both of you
Agreements can be renegotiated

Rule #6: No One You Both Know

What this means:

Not friends, not coworkers, not people in your social circle
Keep outside relationships OUTSIDE your existing life
Reduces drama and complications

If You're Saying No: How to Communicate That

You are ALLOWED to say no. Here's how:

Script #1: The Clear No

"I've thought about this, and I'm not comfortable opening our relationship. I'm monogamous, and that's not going to change. I love you, but this isn't something I can do."

Script #2: The "Not Now, Maybe Not Ever"

"I need more time to think about this. Right now my answer is no, and it might always be no. I'm not making any promises to reconsider. If that's a deal-breaker for you, I understand, but I can't say yes just to keep you."

Script #3: The Boundary

"I hear that this is important to you, but asking me to open our relationship is asking me to be someone I'm not. I need you to accept that monogamy is a boundary for me. If you can't be happy in a monogamous relationship, then we're not compatible."

What Happens Next: The Three Possible Outcomes

Outcome #1: They Accept Your No and Commit to Monogamy

What this looks like: "I understand. Monogamy is important to you, and you're more important than exploring non-monogamy. I'm in."

What you need to watch for:

Do they actually accept it, or are they resentful?
Do they bring it up again later repeatedly?
Are they truly happy with monogamy or just settling?

Can it work? Yes, if they genuinely choose monogamy over non-monogamy. No, if they're just suppressing their desires and will resent you.

Outcome #2: You Agree to Explore Opening the Relationship

What this looks like: You both decide to try, with clear agreements and boundaries.

What you need to watch for:

Is this genuinely mutual or is one person dragging the other along?
Are you both getting what you need?
Is anyone feeling neglected, jealous, or miserable?

Can it work? Yes, if you're both truly enthusiastic and handle jealousy/communication well. No, if one person is doing it to avoid losing the other.

Outcome #3: You're Incompatible and Break Up

What this looks like:

They can't be happy in monogamy
You can't be happy in non-monogamy
You love each other but want fundamentally different things

What you need to know: This is OKAY. This is no one's fault. This is a fundamental incompatibility, like wanting kids vs. not wanting kids.

Can it work? No. And that's sad, but it's better than years of one person being miserable.

The Brutal Truths About Open Relationships

If you're still considering it, you need to know these realities:

Truth #1: It Won't Fix Your Relationship Problems

If you're struggling, opening the relationship will make it worse, not better.

Truth #2: Jealousy Doesn't Just Disappear

Even people who choose non-monogamy experience jealousy. It's about managing it, not eliminating it.

Truth #3: It Requires MORE Communication, Not Less

Open relationships are HARDER than monogamous ones. You're navigating multiple people's needs, feelings, and logistics.

Truth #4: One Person Usually Benefits More

Often, one partner thrives in open relationships while the other struggles. That imbalance can destroy the primary relationship.

Truth #5: Most People Who Open Struggling Relationships Break Up

The success rate for "opening a relationship to save it" is abysmal.

Truth #6: You Can't Unsee Things

Once your partner is with someone else, you can't erase that knowledge. Make sure you can live with that forever.

When to Walk Away Immediately

Some versions of this conversation are automatic deal-breakers:

Immediate Deal-Breaker #1: They're Pressuring or Manipulating You

"If you loved me, you'd try this." "Everyone enlightened is doing this now." "You're being closed-minded."

Response: Leave. This is manipulation.

Immediate Deal-Breaker #2: They've Already Cheated

If they're asking for permission after the fact, that's not ethical non-monogamy. That's cheating with extra steps.

Response: This is betrayal. Decide if you can forgive actual infidelity, not theoretical non-monogamy.

Immediate Deal-Breaker #3: It's an Ultimatum

"I'm going to do this whether you agree or not."

Response: They've already made their choice. Now make yours.

Immediate Deal-Breaker #4: Your Gut Is Screaming No

If every fiber of your being is saying this is wrong for you, listen to that.

Response: Trust yourself. You don't need to justify why monogamy is important to you.

The Bottom Line

Your partner asked to open your relationship. Here's what you need to remember:

✅ You're allowed to say no. Monogamy is not outdated, boring, or less evolved.

✅ You're allowed to say yes. If you're genuinely curious and want to explore, that's valid too.

✅ You're allowed to need time. This isn't a decision you make in a day.

✅ You're allowed to leave. If you're incompatible, that's no one's fault.

✅ "Open relationship" is not one thing. Get clear on what they're actually asking for.

✅ Their feelings are valid AND so are yours. Neither person is wrong—you might just want different things.

The question isn't "Is non-monogamy right or wrong?"

The question is "Is this right for ME?"

And only you can answer that.

If you say yes because you're afraid of losing them, you've already lost yourself.

If you say no and they leave, they weren't your person.

This is a moment of truth about who you are, what you need, and whether you're compatible with your partner.

Whatever you decide, make sure you're choosing based on what YOU want—not fear of what you'll lose.

Your Turn: Have You Navigated This Conversation?

Has your partner asked to open your relationship? How did you handle it? Did you say yes, no, or are you still figuring it out? Share your experience in the comments—your story might help someone else navigate this incredibly difficult conversation!

When Your Partner Hides Purchases and Lies About Spending